Order a Negroni anywhere from Florence to Tbilisi and you will get almost the same thing: a short glass, one big cube of ice, a strip of orange and a drink the colour of stained glass. Gin, Campari and sweet vermouth in equal measure. It is bitter, sweet and strong all at once, and it has become a kind of bartender's handshake, the drink they order when the shift is over. The story of its birth sounds just as neat. Perhaps a little too neat.
The count at Caffè Casoni
The canonical version goes like this. Around 1919, Count Camillo Negroni, a regular at Caffè Casoni on Florence's Via de' Tornabuoni, asked the bartender Fosco Scarselli to give his usual Americano more backbone. Scarselli swapped the soda water for gin and, to mark the difference, garnished it with orange instead of lemon. Other customers started asking for theirs the Negroni way, and the name stuck. The Florentine historian Luca Picchi has done the most to document this account, drawing on the memories of the Scarselli family.
The trouble is paperwork. The historian David Wondrich found that Camillo's claim to be a count is shaky; the title belonged to his grandfather. Descendants of the French general Pascal Olivier de Negroni insist he invented the drink in Senegal in 1857, which is awkward, since Campari did not exist until 1860. And the drink is slow to reach print: a 1929 French book lists a Campari Mixte of equal gin, Campari and Italian vermouth, while recipes under the Negroni name appear only decades later. Florence is the best story we have, not a proven fact.
Before the Negroni, the Americano
What we do know is the parent drink. In the 1860s Gaspare Campari was pouring his bitter red aperitivo at his café in Milan, and the Milanese paired it with vermouth from Turin: the Milano-Torino. Add ice and a splash of soda and you have the Americano, a long, gentle drink that is still one of the best things to sip before dinner. Why Americano? There are plenty of explanations and none is conclusive. Ian Fleming liked it enough to make it James Bond's very first drink in Casino Royale.
Why 1:1:1 works
Equal parts sounds lazy, but it is a clever balance. Campari brings bitterness and the perfume of orange peel, sweet vermouth adds body, spice and sugar, and gin is the backbone, its juniper tying the other two together. Change any one of them and the drink tilts. More gin makes it drier and sharper; more vermouth makes it rounder. Orson Welles, who was filming in Rome at the time, reportedly summed the whole thing up in one line.
The bitters are excellent for your liver, the gin is bad for you. They balance each other.
The family tree
- Negroni Sbagliato: Campari, sweet vermouth and prosecco instead of gin. Credited to Mirko Stocchetto at Bar Basso in Milan, dated to 1967 or 1972 depending on the source, and said to have been born when he grabbed a sparkling wine instead of the gin.
- Boulevardier: bourbon in place of gin. It first appeared in Harry MacElhone's Barflies and Cocktails (Paris, 1927), credited to the writer Erskine Gwynne.
- White Negroni: gin, Suze and Lillet Blanc. Created in Bordeaux in 2001 by the bartender Wayne Collins with Nick Blacknell of Plymouth Gin.
- French Negroni: gin, Lillet and sweet vermouth, softer and more floral, and in our catalogue.
The Sbagliato got a second life in October 2022, when HBO Max posted a clip of House of the Dragon actor Emma D'Arcy describing their favourite drink: a Negroni, Sbagliato, with prosecco in it. The video was watched millions of times, and bars everywhere suddenly had to explain what sbagliato means. It means mistaken. Ironically, that mistake turned out to be the lightest, most summery Negroni of them all.
Negroni Week
Since 2013, Imbibe magazine and Campari have run Negroni Week every September: participating bars pour Negronis and give part of the takings to charity. It began with about 120 venues and now counts thousands, with more than five million dollars raised. Not bad for a drink whose inventor we cannot quite name. Our advice: make one, taste it, then nudge the proportions until it is yours. The count, whoever he really was, would approve.